Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> People seem to forget Linux is only a kernel.

I certainly don't and that's why I'm advocating the userspace shall stay GPL. The freedom has two pillars. Kernel and userspace. If you mow one of the two down, you lose everything.

 help



Yet there are already distros like Chimera Linux and Alpine Linux.

That train is long gone, as folks rather have business friendly FOSS projects.


If we stop fighting for anything just because someone said it's long gone, we'd have nothing.

World's history has changed through wars where some people said that winning [said war] is impossible.

Nothing is set in stone. World is changing more drastically than ever. Assuming that we can't change things or things will stay a certain way is a funny fallacy, at best.

Permanence is an illusion. The pendulum is on the move. It might be moving in a way I don't like, but it can't continue like that forever. I'm just doing what I feel right. I'd rather die trying than regretting that I didn't try.


Well, that is why I dislike Proton, but hey games! Courtesy of Microsoft's ecosystem.

Folks rather have folks friendly FOSS projects :)

There's nothing about using permissive licenses that reduces freedom. Even if someone makes a closed fork of some software down the line, the original will always be there and will still be just as free. Comparing permissive licensing to a loss of freedom is not a valid comparison.

> Even if someone makes a closed fork of some software down the line, the original will always be there and will still be just as free.

Like MinIO, Solaris, Elasticsearch, Hashicorp Suite and countless others. The versions before the license changes are healthy as a doornail. You're absolutely right.

Some of them are re-forked, some did not.

Also, sometimes that closed fork is the only viable option, making the hardware it's running on an expensive doornail. I also don't like that.

I remember using SDKs and software forked from open ones with version numbers like "1.8.7-really1.9.0-internal-thishardwareonly-special-3.2.5-unlocked" which only runs on a distro from 2006 when it's full moon on 29th of February, and the sum of digits of the date is divisible by 7 and 11 at the same time.

Can you patch this? I guess you can, but where's the source? I bet somebody deleted it by accident and it's not present anymore.

Permissive licenses don't take away the four freedoms, but add a fifth one. The ability to take the other four away. Without prior notice. This is what I don't like personally.

In short, I don't like doornails which are not actual doornails. Permissive licenses enable that freedom.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: