I can definitely see the case for that. Ultimately, we're going to need vocabulary for all of the following:
* >=GPT-3.5-level intelligence
* AI that replaces an ordinary human for knowledge work
* AI that replaces an ordinary human for all work (given sufficiently capable hardware)
* AI that replaces any human for knowledge work
* AI that replaces any human for all work (given sufficiently capable hardware)
It doesn't really matter to me which of those we call "AGI" as long as we're consistent. One of them may be AGI, but all of them are important milestones.
* >=GPT-3.5-level intelligence
* AI that replaces an ordinary human for knowledge work
* AI that replaces an ordinary human for all work (given sufficiently capable hardware)
* AI that replaces any human for knowledge work
* AI that replaces any human for all work (given sufficiently capable hardware)
It doesn't really matter to me which of those we call "AGI" as long as we're consistent. One of them may be AGI, but all of them are important milestones.