Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is there a variant that encodes ProRes lossless?

I usually open them up in a new project just to create a lossless input video to work with in After Effects, and use that (if I use image sequence directly, DaVinci Resolve acts in weird ways).

ffmpeg might ease that AE part.



FWIW, ProRes isn’t a lossless codec (tho it should be perceptually lossless in most cases).

Ffmpeg can encode into ProRes, but it’s technically an unofficial implementation.

What issues do you run into with image sequences?


Right, calling it technically lossless is wrong but 422 HQ gives impressive results so I we can probably safely say that it is "practically" lossless.

In DaVinci Resolve, many tools go awry with image sequences: for example temporal noise reduction simply doesn't work with a compound clip with image sequences, I also remember having problems with caching performance. I have a few very strange/buggy problems with Resolve though I love color grading with it regardless, so I want to avoid the buggy sides of Resolve (as it's one of the buggiest software I've ever used) but use the upsides of it (grading and some OpenFX filters).

It would help me on this process.


ffmpeg has 2 prores encoders




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: