Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Back in the late 2000’s I wanted to start a company that broadcasted the current speed limit near signs. Like a BT beacon, sorta, but obvs not BT. It turns out this requires too much coordination. Specifying a protocol, getting manufacturers to build it in, lawmakers to pay for it, sign makers to embed it, etc.

The tech is the easy part.



Isn't this solved by GPS and maps with speed limit data? Google maps gives me nonsense speed limits in a couple of places but mostly correct.


No, because the lower speed limits posted on flashing signs for construction are an important local case.

In my experience, Google just thinks those are traffic jams. I've seen Maps 'know' about road construction speed limits, but it isn't usual.


Good point. Also, M25 (London orbital motorway) has large sections with variable speed limit. Google maps navigation just doesn't show a limit for those areas, since it does not have timely data.


Also the 20mph boroughs really confuse the systems (cars and satnav), since they very often say 30 in 20 and also 20 in a 30. The various limits are, admittedly, not well signed, and I suspect that's deliberate to keep drivers cautious.


One problem is "map matching". That is, given your lat/lng (or, more realistically, a time-series of lat/lngs) and a map, figure out which road you're on.

The thing is that most consumer devices with GPS (like phones and even standalone GPS navigators) have a lot of internal "magic" to hide the raw noise in location fixes from the GPS signal.

For example, certain Garmin devices (intended to be used off road) will snap your location to an Interstate if you are going more than 55 mph and heading roughly in the direction of the road (which is evident when you run into traffic and your location keeps switching between the frontage road and expressway--the error distribution of the noise doesn't have mean=0!).


Out of curiosity, how did the tech deal with things like frontage roads that have much lower speed limits than the highway right next to them.


Basically, they haven't, or at least they hadn't 4 years ago when the car I have with it was made.

Diving along a free flowing 50 and having it decide it's now a 30 because it saw a sideroad and drop a gear is semi-regular. The second most dangerous thing it does after having a touchscreen.

It also manages to read 45 sometimes but I have literally never seen a 45 sign.


Radio waves can be directional. So they were pointed at the road they influenced, not the highway.


If embedded in the sign, what if the sign itself is rotated or damaged in some way?


Our prototype just screwed onto the sign post and could be aimed that way. We never added it to the prototype, but having an accelerometer added to detect movement and shutting down/calling home would help with damage or vandalism.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: