Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> GPS and live traffic data are, essentially, the same service in that they fill the same need

What?

> Restaurant reviews? Who actually needs those except maybe on a road trip?

Anyone who likes to visit new restaurants.



GPS and live traffic data are both "route me to X". I don't think people really have another use case for either, although in some cases the "route me to X" may include "X is a close gas station" or "best route is to wait 45 minutes before leaving".

Do people really choose new restaurants while out (unless on a road trip)? I can see using Yelp while planning to go somewhere with friends, but once you're actually outside the house? In other words, I don't see a use case for Yelp outside the computer, with the exception of a road trip.


> GPS and live traffic data are both "route me to X". I don't think people really have another use case for either, although in some cases the "route me to X" may include "X is a close gas station" or "best route is to wait 45 minutes before leaving".

None of this is true.

> Do people really choose new restaurants while out (unless on a road trip)?

Yes, very often. Maybe I'm at the pub with my partner and we decide to get dinner somewhere. I'll use reviews to find something. It's a very very common use case.


> None of this is true.

Wow, way to fill in use cases I didn't think of.

> Maybe I'm at the pub with my partner and we decide to get dinner somewhere. I'll use reviews to find something.

You go out to a bar before dinner? I suppose some people do. I've always thought of dinner as starting an evening out, or at the very least being part of a plan (eg, Show X followed by dinner at Y)


>You go out to a bar before dinner?

Does it matter? Maybe they wanna look for a bar after dinner then? In which case, you know, the phone is still useful.

>I've always thought of dinner as starting an evening out, or at the very least being part of a plan (eg, Show X followed by dinner at Y)

I'd suggest you look into the idea of spontaneity. It can be pretty great.


The people I know who bother to look at yelp are planners and often choose a restaurant to meet at quite far away because it's special. The people I know who decide things spontaneously don't bother checking yelp.

Since you tried condescending at the end of your comment: I suggest you try places that smell good from the street and not outsource your thinking to an app. It can be pretty great.


>The people I know [...] The people I know

Are you incapable of escaping from your little corner of the world?

>I suggest you try places that smell good from the street and not outsource your thinking to an app.

Guess what? I can, and do, do both!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: