Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In this case, I'm actually not so sure free speech was suppressed.

Businesses have free speech rights in addition to individuals.

Let's take a shop owner as an example. This particular shop owner does not support Trump. They have a community notice board on their shop where people can post things.

Of course they are not going to let a Trump supporter post a MAGA sign on that board. It's their business, they can decide whats allowed there and what isn't. Forcing them to display a MAGA sign would be essentially "forced speech" which would also violate their rights.

That doesn't prevent anyone from making MAGA signs or posting them in other places, so the free speech of those people wasn't violated in any way by the shop owner refusing to display their signs.

Therefore I think Amazon, Apple, Google and the other companies shouldn't be forced to convey messages on their platforms they don't agree with, otherwise it's violating their rights.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: