I tried to put one on my 13" MBP a while back, because I hate how glossy and reflective the screen is. Was horrible to apply, and I ended up with lots of small scratches in the laptop display simply by gently pushing out the air bubbles with a card... I won't be applying a screen protector again in a hurry!

> The desaturation and softness are (AFAIK) inherent to matte screen surfaces and the reason manufacturers nowadays tend to avoid them

If it has to be a choice, then I choose matte regardless.