>I hope not. For what it's worth, I'm still at it and have no plans to stop hosting my own mail!
You misunderstand the point I'm trying to emphasize. I'm not trying to dissuade you from running your own email. There are real benefits to controlling your own email server and it's great you've configured something that works for you.
I'm saying I disagree with how some proponents communicate the drawbacks. They discount (or are blissfully unaware of) the real difficulties of running a personal email server for critical outgoing emails.
In the previous thread and this one, there are several of us with decades of email admin experience saying it is tricky to debug "sender reputation" while the opposing side insists Gmail/MSOutlook spamholes are easy to fix and not a big deal. Therefore, one of the sides misunderstands the realities. With these conflicting accounts, readers contemplating running their own email server will have to decide who is more accurately reporting the state of the email ecosystem for personal servers.
The author (Tomaž Šolc) of the article discussed in this thread had ~15 years experience administering his own email servers and tried to do all the "correct" things as an upstanding citizen of the email ecosystem and yet his emails still suddenly got rejected by Gmail. Readers will have to conclude if he got bit by forces out of his control -- or
-- he's incompetent and doesn't know what he's doing. (From my point of view, the author wasn't incompetent and his frustrations with Gmail's filter is a common reality. Maybe this time, he can update DMARC to fix Gmail rejections... for now. But eventually, a new Google AI spam algorithm will mysteriously reject his server's emails again.)
Fair points. I don't have much to add to your comment, so I'll just say that I was nodding along with every paragraph. Thanks for clarifying what you meant to emphasize, I think I understand now!
You misunderstand the point I'm trying to emphasize. I'm not trying to dissuade you from running your own email. There are real benefits to controlling your own email server and it's great you've configured something that works for you.
I'm saying I disagree with how some proponents communicate the drawbacks. They discount (or are blissfully unaware of) the real difficulties of running a personal email server for critical outgoing emails.
In the previous thread and this one, there are several of us with decades of email admin experience saying it is tricky to debug "sender reputation" while the opposing side insists Gmail/MSOutlook spamholes are easy to fix and not a big deal. Therefore, one of the sides misunderstands the realities. With these conflicting accounts, readers contemplating running their own email server will have to decide who is more accurately reporting the state of the email ecosystem for personal servers.
The author (Tomaž Šolc) of the article discussed in this thread had ~15 years experience administering his own email servers and tried to do all the "correct" things as an upstanding citizen of the email ecosystem and yet his emails still suddenly got rejected by Gmail. Readers will have to conclude if he got bit by forces out of his control -- or -- he's incompetent and doesn't know what he's doing. (From my point of view, the author wasn't incompetent and his frustrations with Gmail's filter is a common reality. Maybe this time, he can update DMARC to fix Gmail rejections... for now. But eventually, a new Google AI spam algorithm will mysteriously reject his server's emails again.)