Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your comment was making an implied link between the difficulties in the US healthcare system and the 11 million illegal immigrants - whether you intended or not (if you didn't, there'd be next to no reason to bring up illegal immigration at all).

Why would illegal immigration have any impact on healthcare, unless you were implying that they were a drain on the system (which is an assertion needing to be backed up by facts)?



My comment was making an implied link between many different things, illegal immigration being one of them. As it has an impact on the complexity os the US healthcare system and is one of the reasons why you can't just have a Scandinavian model.

There is a world of difference between a small homogenous group of countries where everyone pays more or less the same taxes their whole life and where immigration is fairly limited and then a country like the US where people arrive often later in life after they grew up other places and before they start paying taxes to the system.

Healthcare budgets are built up over decades not just year over year. It's based on people when they are young and don't cost too much for the system pays to the system so that when they grow older they are offset by younger generations again.

11 million people who live partly outside the system even when they pay taxes is a big number and since they live concentrated in around 20 metropolitan areas almost half of them in 3 states that make them an actual issue on top of the other things as they are not just distributed across the entire country.

In what universe it's racist to point out that illegal immigrants adds to the complexity of why the US can't have the scandinavian model is beyond me. You are the only one making illegal immigration a matter of race for some absurd reason.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: