Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The review doesnt tell you that you cannot upgrade or replace your SSD.


Or boot Linux, because the T2 chip prevents it[1].

[1] https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Apple-T2...


Why would you buy this to run Linux?


Well, I certainly wouldn't, but in four to five years if I need a general purpose server, it'd be nice to install Linux.


That turned out to be rubbish. You can easily disable secure boot.


From the link:

> Update 2: It looks like even if disabling the Secure Boot functionality, the T2 chip is reportedly still blocking operating systems aside from macOS and Windows 10.

That seems to contradict your claim, and I haven't seen that refuted elsewhere.



Yes, you can disable Secure Boot, but Linux still isn't allowed to access the NVMe device.


I will never again buy a laptop or computer where I can’t replace the SSD myself.

Last time I had a problem with my MacBook Pro and took it in to get fixed. They wanted me to write down my login password before they would accept it!

I had to reschedule and wiped my disk before bringing it back again.


Another way of looking at that is that macs are so secure even apple can’t get into them without your password.


So if the motherboard dies, all your data is gone?


You should use backups anyway. ‍️

But if the computer dies and the motherboard survives, you can connect to some thingy on the board to get the data.


You can, or Apple can for a fee?


Apple products are anti consumer and anti developer.

I consider using Apple products on par with using Keurig, its bad capitalism.


Which also means the entire thing has to be thrown out when the SSD eventually dies. Sure it's going to take a while, but it will happen. Yay consumerism, I guess.


In late 2014 I replaced the disks in my 2008 Mac Pro at work and my 2009 Mac Pro at home with Samsung EVO 840 and 850 SSD disks. I kept track of accumulated writes.

Both machines were heavily used for development and consumer type stuff. No big data stuff or big media stuff.

Samsung rates these things at 150 TB write endurance for the 850 and something around 120 TB for the 840.

My projection based on that usage is that it will take over 35 years to reach 100 TB.

Samsung's ratings are quite conservative. Reviewers that have put these things through write torture tests to the point of error have typically gotten several times Samsung's rating. Around 170 years worth of writes at my usage rate.

I haven't seen numbers for Apple's durability, but if it is within even distant sight of Samsung's EVO performance you can expect to have retired the computer for other reasons long before the SSD dies.

I'd expect that the only reason the SSD might lead to getting a new computer is that you want a bigger SSD, but even that might not be an issue because Thunderbolt 3 gives pretty good performance for external disks.

My Mac Pros have both been retired, replaced with a 2017 iMac (one iMac could replace both office and work computer because we switched to working at home). My Samsung EVOs are now on the iMac in an AKiTiO Thunder3 Quad Mini enclosure.

The internal SSD in the iMac gets just short of 2000 MB/s for both read and write, according to Disk Speed Test from Blackmagic Design. The Samsung EVOs get around 465 MB/s write, 520 MB/s read, so 1/4 the internal disk but still fast enough for most purposes.

Note that the Samsungs are SATA drives. Something that made more direct use of TB3 could probably go much faster.


I bought a 1TB Samsung 840 Evo in September 2013, and it just died last month. So it was in operation for around 5 years.

I used it for development type stuff. It outlasted the 2011 MBP I bought it for. In fact, I ran it on 3 different computers during its life span.

Overall, I'm pretty happy that it got the 5 years. With spindles, I prefer to replace them every 2 years to avoid headaches.


Technically not. You can boot from an external thunderbolt SSD, which is capable of the same speeds as an internal drive. It’s mildly ugly, but not a showstopper.

But I thought that modern SSDs were supposed to last decades, even under heavy use. Is this actually a real problem?


Does anyone know if TRIM is supported using an external SSD over thunderbolt?

I remember reading it’s not supported over USB3.


My wife is using her iMac with an external SSD via USB3 since the HDD is too slow. She even can boot her Macbook Air from the macOS installation on that same SSD and keep working.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: